It was the BEST / MOST EPIC THING EVER!!!!

I thoroughly enjoyed it, but it wasn't the "best thing ever".

It was a fun little indulgence for the fans, but I'd prefer to ignore it in the rest of the show's context.

It wasn't terrible, but it left a bit of a bad taste in my mouth.

It was the WORST THING EVER!!!

I can't take it in. / I don't know what to feel.